1) I don't like being a reporter
2) Print journalism was dying
I was horrified by the thought of traditional newspapers becoming extinct. The fact that I didn't really want to work for one anymore took the sting off, but being sentimental and somewhat idealistic, I thought of the amazing history of newspapers with remorse. From the romanticized history found in stories such as
The Newsies
To the heavy-hitting, historical exposes like the Watergate Scandal
It seemed like such a tragedy to lose such an important part of our history and culture to the all-consuming beast of market demands. Sure, online newspapers are significantly more efficient, waste-free, cost-effective, and convenient, but what about tradition. That being said, I must admit that I have never subscribed to a newspaper in my life, and actively avoid the junior high children that go door-to-door in our community hawking them. But the loss still hurts a little.
Well, so what?
I'll tell you what. After abandoning my hopes for a Pulitzer, my interests evolved into literature and editing and publishing. Seemed like a safe bet, yes? The most beloved form of past-time in the last 150 years, cherished generation after generation? Yeah, that's job security, my friend.
Then a couple years later, I heard about a thing called a Kindle, and thought, "Who would want that? Sounds expensive." Four years and one Kindle later, I became a convert. They're just so dang easy. Instead of taking 15 books on a road trip to appease my ADD, I now just take my tiny little Kindle and I suddenly have a book for any possible mood I'm in, and it takes up hardly any space. Not to mention that e-books are on average $5-$10 cheaper than their printed counterparts.
Now, just as I begin basking in my new e-book freedom, something catches my eye. It's my bookshelf, packed to bursting point with all my dog-eared favorites of days past. I get sentimental again. I remember how it felt to pick out a new book, the ease with which I flipped through it if I needed to go back and read something, and the comfort of knowing that if I step on it, I will still be able to read it.
In order to compromise my guilt and my need for excellent deals, I typically only buy books on my Kindle that I a) don't think are worth buying in real life, but I'm curious, and b) I don't want to buy in hard back but I want to read right away. But what about everyone else? Has the lure of e-books, with their shiny new features, touch screens, and interactive options, encouraged people to forsake their roots and favorite paperbacks?
Is print publishing...
dying?
If so, then that is unfortunate timing for me, who seems to be jumping from one sinking ship to another. But my employment future aside, what does that mean for literature, more specifically the novel?
In order to explore this question further, I have designed this blog to look first at the history of the novel, then I will conduct an experiment regarding the newer publication styles, and finally will discuss where the novel is heading and what it could mean for all of us. But first, I want to hear what you have to say! Is print publishing on its way out? Are e-readers the superior way to engage with literature? What has your experience been? Do you think this debate is stupid? Do you think this blog is stupid? Let me know down below in the Comments section and see some other opinions. Then, take the plunge into theory with The History of the Novel.
I'm already excited about this blog, and I'd like to share my thoughts with you after reading just this post.
ReplyDeleteI am also sentimental with my books. As much as technology is convenient, I don't believe I'll ever truly convert away from tangible pages. I love holding them too much.
However, that being said, I can't say the same for the world population. It seems that, more and more, what people want is convenience; people want access to everything without the pain of hauling it around on their backs. And in this technological age, I find it more likely for some to read an ebook than they would an actual bound copy if the two were placed before them. I'm sad to say that between convenience and the urge to conserve resources, our love of that new (and old) book smell will likely become something of a myth in the future.
My opinion? Use e-reader's all you want, but let me keep reading from a printed page. In my limited experience with readers, I have found very little to like. They feel awkward in my hands, I can't just flip to any page (I've heard of features added to simulate this, but they wouldn't do the trick for me), and they are expensive and more fragile than I would like them to be.
ReplyDeleteI love the concept of having an actual bookshelf with actual books, and I reject the notion that digitizing something is necessarily an improvement. We have already seen the demise of most good places to rent movies as a result of Netflix and Redbox. This is just one example of negative effects stemming from a move to an online or automatic format. I don't mean to suggest that the exact same situation will happen with books, but I do think it ought to encourage caution.
But here, I've only considered user-end effects of e-books and e-readers. I can't even imagine the outcomes on the end of the author. Who knows if writing styles will change significantly, if novels will explode or die out?
In any case, I'll continue to get print on paper at my local library.
I still love reading books from the shelf. One of the best things about my living room is that everyone gets to learn more about me when they see what I like to read.
ReplyDeleteI don't have a kindle, but I'm usually slow to try new fads. Once I finally catch on, I'm "all in" and lose interest in the past way of doing things (for the most part).
My conclusion: I love tradition, but I'll love the new fad more, once I finally catch on. - Melissa
i don't like reading books on a kindle. i like reading the actual physical book because its more personal and I can highlight or leave comments.
ReplyDeleteI love print anything, and I much prefer books over kindles and newspapers over online articles. Although I think that online sources are much more convenient, I think that books, newspapers, and print journalism are art forms that we should try and keep! There is just something so irreplaceable and magical about the pages of a book and bookshelves full of them.
ReplyDeleteSorry it took me so long to make it here. We're actually talking about this in my Digital Culture class (you should take it. It's really interesting). But I think the main thing is, even if print is obsolete, it's only because the media is finding a new medium. The Internet/technology aren't killing books or newspaper; it's just a change of venue. I don't see the idea or form of novels changing much, especially since online newspapers haven't changed. It will change the publishing profession, maybe, since publishing costs will go down thanks to epublishing and self publishing and freelance editing. Jobs are being...outsourced to freelancers who come cheaper, etc. which is good and bad: good for writers who are bound to get a better cut, bad for those who want a career as an editor...like me. Go figure.
ReplyDeleteWhy should the kindle get to stomp around like a giant, while the printed book tries not to get smushed under its big feet? What's so great about the kindle? Hm? Books are just as cute as kindles. Books are just as smart as kindles. People totally like books just as much as they like kindles. And when did it become okay for the kindle to be the boss of everybody, huh? Because that's not what reading is about. We should totally just *stab* the kindle!
ReplyDeletein all seriousness, i prefer the actual, printed book. reading off a computer is slow and awkward for me. i've never tried a kindle, but i have no interest to try either.
ReplyDeleteMy comment was too long... It told me that I have exceeded the number of characters allowed in a comment, so I am going to post this in sections!
ReplyDeleteSection 1 - Pro's:
1. The first and most important thing I love about the Kindle is that I have all my books in one location. When I used to travel I would have to bring two or three books in my carry-on, which took up quite a bit of space, but now I can bring my small and compact kindle and that takes care of everything. I am able to have what ever books that I will want for the whole trip in one space saving device.
2. The books are cheaper! This has proved great since I have been what you call poor for the last few years. Also, I have a great mom who continues to give me Amazon gift cards, and I am able to stretch them farther when I buy books for the kindle instead of the paperback versions.
3. If I am reading some trashy teenage garbage, NO ONE IN THE WORLD HAS TO KNOW!!! (This totally would have helped us all during the Twilight years!) LOL! Let's be honest, sometimes I am ashamed to admit to what I am reading... This helps.
That is the extent of my pro list. All in all I don't LOVE the kindle the way that other's do. I also, do not HATE the kindle as others do... but, if it came down to having to choose one or the other I will pick the hard copy, hands down every time. My con's list is in fact much longer.
Section 2 - Con's:
ReplyDelete1. I just like the feel of having a real book in my hand. I know that this has been the age ol' argument against the kindle since the kindle came out and it might sound a little cliché to say it. But, it's true. I love the feeling of a great paperback book in my hands. I don't know how to explain it. It has some thing to do with the feel of the paper... I know this isn't well argued, but it's true.
2. I can NEVER find my place on my kindle. I love to flip back and reference things as I read and I also am a big flip forwarder to figure out how far I have to read till I get to a certain point. On my kindle I cant just flip forward to page 362 or flip back to page 63 to re-read what so-and-so said to so-and-so. I feel completely lost the entire time I read. This is the biggest, number one reason I hate reading on my kindle. I find that I completely loose the ability to wander around in my book. And to me wandering around in a book is an important part of reading. I have tried to overcome this issue and I find that no matter how much you bookmark, or learn how to use the navigation system on the kindle it is just not easy to flip back like you can in a book.
3. It's electronic. Period. This leads to two problems; a) when you are on an airplane you have to turn it off during take-off and landing. My favorite time to read in a flight is during take off... You can see my problem. and b) when you loose the power cord eventually you will run out of power and then have no book. Eventually if you have no outlet then you will have no book. Now I know that is a little dramatic because let's be honest most of us will always have power, but I have had my kindle die completely twice now, and it's a pain to have to wait for the thing to charge enough to turn back on and then be stuck to the wall for the time being while the thing charges for the next two hours. (sorry for the run on sentence).
4. (This one has to do with a personal preference of mine that no one else probably has... but, worth putting on here since it's one of the biggest negatives I feel toward the Kindle). I am slightly OCD about my books. I love having books on the shelf. I also Love having my books all match as well. If I am buying a series of books and the first one I buy is in Paperback then ALL of the books have to be in paperback so that when they sit next to each other they match. If the first one is bought in hardback then again they have to match so they all have to be in hard back. What does this have to do with my kindle you might ask? I have found that due to my OCD nature about my book collections I have bought most of my books twice. I have my shelf book and my Kindle book... FRUSTRATING! So when the book cost less on the kindle (#2 on the pro list) in reality it ends up costing me MORE due to my need for it to match on the shelf. This has turned out to be one of the biggest issues I have with the kindle... I have my hard copy of Hunger Games and my Kindle version... I have my hard copy of Ender's Game and my kindle version... I have my hard copy of those trashy books that I can't even name, but am sticking out all crapy 9 of them (ok only 3 of the 9 are crapy) and then I have my kindle version. 18 of the 21 purchased books on my kindle I have in a hard copy form... so, in essence it hasn't been cheaper.
Section 2 Continued...
ReplyDelete5. You are unable to take notes. I know you can add a "highlight" but you aren't able to actually write in the book. I know who actually writes in their books novels? Right? Let's just say I have been known to from time to time. Enough said on this subject.
6. There's permanent "highlights" that I didn't put there. I hate when I am reading on my kindle and up pops a pre-placed "highlight." It just throws off the flow of my reading. If I want to highlight a sentence in my book I will, I don't need to know what everyone else is thinking.
7. I like the look of books on a shelf... Nothing else to say about that. Except one day I want to have a library, I want a room that all 4 walls are made out of floor to celling bookshelf's that are covered in books.
8. I have a fear that future generations will loose what we have if we move to just electronic copies. I know this seems stupid, but there is nothing cooler than to hold a 200 year old book in your hands. Or to look at a book that was made (hand done) in the 14th century. I know this seems stupid, but I have a legitimate fear 300 years from now the people on earth will have nothing to show for the 21st century. Believe me I saw Jefferson's library this last month and there was nothing cooler than knowing that he could have staid up all night reading this specific book. and that he held this book with his own hands. and he turned these pages. and he left hand written notes on these pages. I don't want us to loose that as a society.
I don't hate my Kindle. I just don't love it the way other people do.
I think the hardest part about this was actually sitting down and writing out my rant. I was talking to Bryan about this and I had all these opinions, but now as I sit down they all leave my mind. Hopefully they will come back to me.
ReplyDeleteLike many others I feel that I have a love/hate relationship with my Kindle. Okay, love/hate is a little strong, but you know what I mean.
I think what is most off with me is that I don’t literally “see” the value of buying a book on Kindle like I do when I have a physical book in my hand. I know that doesn’t make any sense since what I’m really paying for is the story, but I feel like without the paper and binding the story is worth less. So even if the Kindle version is $5 less than the paperback, I’d rather have the paperback. To be honest, I don’t like buying any Kindle book that’s more than $5. If it is over $5, I’d rather pay the extra money for the physical book. Sad since I know I’m killing trees and taking up space that I don’t have.
Then again, most of the time I would rather borrow a book from the library than either of the above. If the Provo Library ebook website actually worked (I’ve tried to “borrow” them loads of times and it never has worked for me) I think I would be the most happy. Seriously if there was a website for books like there is Netflix for movies or Audible for audiobooks where I could pay a monthly fee and “rent” as many books as I wanted for 3 weeks or something, I would probably never buy another book. Unless of course it was something amazingly awesome like Hunger Games or Harry Potter—you just have to buy those.
But I do love the convenience of the Kindle—how light and small it is—and how hip I look while reading it. Plus no one can see the cover of the book when you are reading some stupid teenage chick-lit book that you never want anyone to know you read. That’s always nice. So I don’t know. I love real books. I love my Kindle. I will probably continue buying both unless some new crazy technology comes along that can automatically upload books into my brain.
So I ended up deleting a page from this that had some good comments, so I copy/pasted them here:
ReplyDeleteFrom Terri:
I was originally a hard-sell on ebooks. Or e-justaboutanything! But the more I force myself to adapt the more I see the perks! (I hade adapting!) There is something to be said for the convenience! I will always want to keep those old favorites on a bookshelf somewhere gathering dust until I get back to them, like an old forgotten friend. (They're very forgiving that way!) And I believe certain things should ALWAYS be printed - like the Bible, the Constitution, Historical Documents, etc. And personal journals, and personal notes to each-other written in ones own hand. Those should still exist in an otherwise e-world! But...if we must adapt...it sure is handy to pull out the old kindle whereever and whenever and read anything I want! Hate to admit it, but e-books win in the end. Unless, of course, you step on them. (Which I did, and have been sad ever since, and pulled out the old dusty books!)
From Anonymous:
I have always been (and hopefully always will be) a public library girl. I guess it was just a tradition my dad passed on to me at an early age as we would go down to the local library and check out as many books as I could reasonably carry. I'll never forget passing those hard copies back and for with my dad because he always made a point of reading the books I brought home and discussing them with me. We owned some books, but we never could have afforded to buy a quarter of the books we read. Now everyone around me, including family members, is slowly converting to kindles and IPads. My dad stuck to his library hard copies till he died a year ago, and I feel sentimentally bound to carry on that tradition. Screens may be conveniently portable, but a book will never break or die, and I think that should count for something too.
From: deletedtoprotecttheinnocent:
ReplyDeleteAn egregious ommission is being perpetrated in this discussion. How quickly we forget one of the most powerful forces in modern literature: USED BOOKS. I don't pay full price for a book, thanks to DI, Goodwill, pawn shops, dumpster-dives and AMAZON. Oh, did I omit the library? Has anyone ever bought a second hand e-book? I'll see your $5-$10 discounts and lower you 80 to 100 percent! Ever sat on a Kindle because you are too short? Ever propped the door open with an e-book? Ever seen a baby eat a page of electronic media? Ever lined the bird cage with..., well you get the picture. Besides, since everyone has one, what guy or gal is impressed with a member of the opposite sex staggering around under a backpack full of Kindle?
Not me! Books rule!